the use of water hammer pressure is different:
Clamped check valve small size, short flap travel, and spring-assisted closure, shutdown speed; flanged check valve large size, long flap travel type, need a longer closure time.
size and weight comparison:
Clamp check valve structure length is very short, small volume, light weight, for the valve device, handling, storage and pipeline arrangement to bring great convenience, and can save a lot of information, reduce the cost; flange check valve structure length is very long, the volume is large, the weight is very heavy.
the application of different fluid resistance:
Clamp check valve resistance is small, fluid resistance coefficient ξ for 2.6 ~ 2.7, followed by the increase in valve calibre, the fluid resistance coefficient decreases; flange check valve is more small, the fluid resistance coefficient ξ for 1.3 ~ 3, but in low-pressure conditions, the valve flap can not be completely open, the fluid resistance is large. Fluid resistance increases with the increase of valve calibre.
the method of device is different:
Clamped check valve can be installed horizontally or straight device, light weight, do not have to set up support for the valve; flange check valve horizontal device, large diameter valve weight, need to set up support.
the size of the open pressure is not the same:
Clamp check valve open very small, the valve can be completely open under a small pressure difference; flange check valve open pressure is larger, the valve can be completely open under a larger pressure difference.
the reliability of the valve is different:
Clamped check valve for the whole structure, simple and compact, the valve is closed when the impact force is small, water hammer pressure is small, the valve has a long life, high reliability; flange check valve closed when the huge impact force and water hammer pressure is easy to damage the valve.
