Why Swing Check Valves Develop Problems
A swing check valve closes by allowing a hinged disc to fall back onto the seat once the forward flow stops. The design is simple and gives a low pressure drop when fully open, but the long travel of the disc and its dependence on flow reversal mean that the closing behaviour is governed by the flow conditions in the line rather than by the valve alone. Most reported problems with swing check valves can be traced to that characteristic, combined with incorrect sizing or an unsuitable installation.
The Principal Problems and Their Causes
| Problem | Usual cause | Effect on the system |
|---|---|---|
| Seat leakage in the closed position | Damaged or worn seating surfaces, soft seat degradation, foreign particles trapped at the seat | Continuous loss of efficiency, reverse flow and possible contamination of the upstream line |
| Disc slam and pressure surge | Long disc travel and slow closing, with the disc accelerated back by reverse flow | Noise and vibration, water hammer in liquid lines, fatigue damage to pipe supports and fittings |
| Hinge pin and disc wear | Continuous disc movement and impact at every closure, aggravated by high cycle rates | Misalignment of the disc on the seat, increasing leakage and eventual failure to close |
| Jamming or blockage | Dirt, scale, weld slag or fibrous material lodged between the disc and the body | The disc is held open, so the valve no longer prevents backflow |
| Chattering at low flow | An oversized valve in which the disc cannot stay fully open | Rapid disc oscillation, seat damage and noise |
| High pressure drop | Undersized body, partially open disc, or a valve installed against the flow arrow | Increased pumping cost and reduced flow capacity of the line |
| Unsuitable for some media | Suspended solids, high viscosity liquids or slurries | Deposits on the hinge and seat, accelerated wear and sticking |
Effects on the System
Seat leakage and disc wear reduce the reliability of the non-return function and may allow reverse flow into pumps or process equipment. Disc slam is more serious: the pressure surge generated by a rapidly closing disc travels through the pipework and can damage supports, gaskets, instruments and the pump itself. In pump discharge duty the surge is often noticed as pipe movement and banging immediately after a pump trip. Chattering produces continuous noise and erodes the seating surfaces, so the valve degrades faster than its design life suggests.
Practical Solutions
Size the valve for the actual flow range so that the disc stays fully open in normal operation, and accept a slightly higher pressure drop instead of an oversized body.
Use a spring-assisted or damped design where the closing speed must be controlled, since the spring starts closing the disc before reverse flow develops.
Consider a dual plate check or a lift check where space is limited or where a short closing stroke is preferred, especially on pump discharge lines.
Select a seat and disc material suited to the medium, and specify a hard-faced seat for abrasive or high temperature service.
Fit a strainer or filter upstream where the line carries dirt, scale or construction debris, and flush the line before commissioning.
Install the valve in the direction of the flow arrow, with the recommended straight length upstream so that the disc is not held open by turbulence.
Follow the manufacturer installation position for the pattern supplied, since some swing check designs are sensitive to orientation.
Inspection and Maintenance
Inspection intervals should be set from the criticality of the duty and the cleanliness of the medium. During a shutdown the seating surfaces, the disc and the hinge pin are the parts to examine, together with the body and cover gaskets. A valve that has chattered for a long period usually shows fretting on the hinge pin and a worn contact area on the disc. Where repeated seat leakage is found, the correct response is often to change the valve type or size rather than to replace the seat alone.
FAQ
Q: What is the biggest problem with swing check valves?
Disc slam is the most damaging problem in liquid service, because the disc closes at the moment of flow reversal and the resulting surge can damage the pipework. Seat leakage and hinge pin wear are the most common maintenance problems.
Q: Why does a swing check valve cause water hammer?
The disc has a long travel and closes only after the flow reverses, so a slug of liquid is stopped abruptly and its momentum is converted into a pressure wave in the pipeline.
Q: How can water hammer from a check valve be reduced?
Selecting a spring-assisted, damped or dual plate design that closes before the flow reverses reduces the surge. Correct sizing so that the disc stays fully open, and shortening the closing travel, both help.
Q: Are swing check valves suitable for lines carrying solids?
They are not the best choice. Solids and fibres can lodge between the disc and the body and hold the valve open, so strainers or a different check valve design are normally preferred.
Q: Why does a swing check valve chatter?
Chattering is caused by an oversized valve operating below the flow needed to hold the disc fully open, so the disc oscillates on its hinge and damages the seat.
Q: Does a swing check valve need to be installed horizontally?
Installation depends on the pattern. The flow arrow must always point in the direction of flow, and the recommended orientation for the specific design should be followed, particularly on vertical lines.
