Knowledge

Water Hammer in Piping Systems: Causes, Effects & Prevention

Mar 13, 2024 Leave a message

Water hammer, also called hydraulic shock or a hydraulic transient, occurs when the velocity of a moving liquid changes rapidly.

When flowing liquid is forced to slow down or stop, its momentum is converted into a pressure wave. The wave travels through the piping system and can reflect at valves, fittings, changes in pipe diameter, tanks, and other boundaries.

A common example is a pump discharge line with a check valve. When the pump trips, the forward flow may slow down and reverse. If the check valve does not close before significant reverse flow develops, the valve disc can slam against the seat and generate a pressure surge.

Water hammer is not limited to water. Similar hydraulic transients can occur with many liquids, including process chemicals, hydrocarbons, and other incompressible or relatively incompressible fluids.

 

What Causes Water Hammer?

Water hammer is usually associated with a rapid change in fluid velocity. Common causes include the following.

1. Rapid Valve Closure

A fast-closing valve can bring a moving liquid column to a sudden stop.

The faster the effective flow reduction, the greater the potential pressure surge. This is why valve operating time and actuator settings matter in long pipelines, high-flow systems, and high-pressure applications.

Quarter-turn valves such as ball valves and butterfly valves can close relatively quickly, so their actuator closing profile should be considered carefully when water hammer is a concern.

A valve should not automatically be labeled as "bad" because it closes quickly. The acceptable closing time depends on the piping system and the transient response of the complete installation.

2. Pump Shutdown or Trip

A sudden pump trip can create a hydraulic transient even when no operator is closing a valve.

After the pump stops, the liquid column may decelerate rapidly and, depending on the system head and pipeline profile, flow may reverse.

This is a common cause of check valve slam in pump discharge systems.

3. Check Valve Slam

Check valves are designed to prevent sustained reverse flow, but they do not all close in the same way.

A swing check valve, for example, may require reverse flow to move the disc toward the seat. If the reverse velocity becomes significant before the disc closes, the disc can strike the seat with considerable force.

Spring-assisted, axial, nozzle, or other non-slam check valve designs may reduce this problem when properly selected for the application.

However, replacing a check valve alone does not guarantee that water hammer will disappear. The pump, pipeline length, elevation profile, flow velocity, and other system characteristics also need to be considered.

4. Sudden Pump Start-Up

Starting a pump too quickly can also produce a hydraulic transient because the liquid velocity changes rapidly.

Pump starting and stopping procedures, variable-frequency drives, control valves, and system bypass arrangements can all affect the severity of the transient.

5. Flow Reversal and Column Separation

A rapid pressure drop can cause the local pressure in a liquid pipeline to fall very low. In severe cases, the liquid column may separate or vapor cavities may form.

When these cavities collapse, the resulting pressure spike can be more damaging than the original pressure drop.

This is one reason that hydraulic transient analysis should consider both positive pressure surges and negative pressure transients.

 

What Problems Can Water Hammer Cause?

Water hammer does more than make a loud banging noise.

Repeated or severe pressure transients can cause:

Valve seat and disc damage

Check valve slam

Flange and gasket leakage

Pipe joint movement

Pipe support vibration

Pump and equipment damage

Excessive pressure loading on fittings

Pipe deformation or rupture

Low-pressure conditions and column separation

Cavitation-related damage in some systems

Unplanned shutdowns and maintenance

The actual risk depends on the magnitude and duration of the transient and the pressure rating and mechanical strength of the piping system.

A system operating below its normal design pressure is not automatically protected from water hammer. A short-duration pressure spike can still exceed the allowable pressure of a component.

 

How Is Water Hammer Pressure Estimated?

For a simple first-pass estimate, engineers often use the Joukowsky equation:

ΔP = ρaΔV

Where:

ΔP = pressure change

ρ = fluid density

a = pressure-wave speed

ΔV = change in fluid velocity

This equation shows why high fluid velocity and rapid deceleration can produce a large pressure surge.

However, the Joukowsky equation is not a complete transient analysis for a real piping system.

Actual peak pressure can be affected by:

Pipeline length

Pipe wall thickness and material

Fluid properties

Valve characteristics

Valve closure profile

Pump characteristics

Pipeline elevation

Branches and fittings

Pressure-wave reflections

Check valve behavior

Air or vapor pockets

Surge-control equipment

For critical systems, hydraulic transient simulation is normally more appropriate than relying on a simple hand calculation.

 

Why Valve Closing Time Matters

One of the most practical ways to reduce water hammer is to avoid an unnecessarily rapid change in flow velocity.

For a simple pipeline, the pressure-wave travel time is related to the pipe length and wave speed. A commonly used reference is the pipeline communication time:

t = 2L/a

Where:

t = characteristic wave travel time

L = pipeline length

a = pressure-wave speed

If a valve closes much faster than the hydraulic communication time, the system can experience a much larger pressure rise than with a slower closure.

However, total actuator stroke time is not always the same as effective closure time. Valve flow characteristics mean that some parts of the stroke may have a much greater effect on flow than others.

Therefore, simply specifying "close the valve in 10 seconds" does not guarantee that water hammer will be controlled.

For critical systems, the valve's installed flow characteristic and actual closing profile should be evaluated together with the piping system.

 

 

How to Prevent Water Hammer

There is no single valve or device that solves every water hammer problem.

The most effective solution depends on the source of the transient.

1. Slow Down Valve Closure

If rapid valve closure is the main cause, increasing the closing time can reduce the pressure surge.

For actuated valves, the actuator or control system may be configured with a controlled closing profile rather than a simple fast open/fast close action.

This approach is often one of the simplest changes to consider because it does not require replacing the entire valve.

2. Select the Right Check Valve

When water hammer occurs during pump shutdown, check valve selection deserves particular attention.

Depending on the application, options may include:

Swing check valves

Dual-plate check valves

Spring-loaded check valves

Axial-flow check valves

Nozzle check valves

Silent or non-slam check valves

The objective is not simply to choose the valve with the fastest closing speed.

The valve should close in a controlled manner before excessive reverse flow develops while maintaining acceptable pressure loss during normal operation.

3. Control Pump Start-Up and Shutdown

Pump control can have a major effect on hydraulic transients.

Possible measures include:

Controlled pump ramp-up

Controlled pump shutdown

Variable-frequency drives

Appropriate pump sequencing

Bypass arrangements

Coordinated pump and valve operation

The best solution depends on the pump curve and the hydraulic characteristics of the system.

4. Use Surge-Control Equipment When Necessary

For systems with unavoidable or severe transients, additional protection may be required.

Depending on the application, engineers may consider:

Surge vessels

Accumulators

Surge tanks

Air or vacuum valves

Pressure relief or surge-relief devices

Hydraulic dampers

These devices must be correctly sized and located. Adding a surge device without analyzing the system can solve one transient while creating another.

5. Reduce Excessive Flow Velocity

Higher flow velocity generally increases the pressure change associated with a given velocity reduction.

Increasing pipe diameter can reduce flow velocity for a given flow rate, although this is normally a design-stage solution and may not be economical for an existing pipeline.

6. Analyze the Complete Piping System

If the consequences of water hammer are serious, do not treat the valve as an isolated component.

A transient analysis should consider the interaction between:

Pump → Check Valve → Pipeline → Isolation/Control Valve → Tank or Header

The location of the valve, pipeline length, elevation changes, operating sequence, and boundary conditions can all affect the result.

 

Check Valve Factory

Dual-plate check valves
Swing check valves
Swing check valves
Swing check valves
 
 
 
 

Need Help Choosing a Valve for a Water Hammer Problem?
Share your valve size, pressure class, flow rate, fluid, pump information, and current operating conditions. Our valve engineers can help you identify the likely cause and recommend a suitable valve solution.

Send Your Valve Requirements

 

FAQ

1. What is the main cause of water hammer?

The main cause is a rapid change in liquid velocity. Common triggers include fast valve closure, pump shutdown, pump start-up, and check valve slam.

 

2. Can a check valve cause water hammer?

Yes. A check valve can contribute to water hammer if it closes after significant reverse flow has already developed. This is commonly called check valve slam.

 

3. Does a non-slam check valve eliminate water hammer?

Not necessarily.

A properly selected non-slam check valve can reduce water hammer caused by delayed check-valve closure, but it cannot eliminate a transient generated elsewhere in the piping system.

 

4. Does closing a valve slowly prevent water hammer?

It can reduce the pressure surge, but the required closing profile depends on the system. Total actuator stroke time alone is not enough to determine whether a valve will cause excessive water hammer.

 

5. Which check valve is best for preventing water hammer?

There is no universally best check valve.

Silent, nozzle, axial-flow, spring-assisted, and other controlled-closing designs may be suitable depending on the pump, flow rate, pressure, installation, and transient characteristics.

 

6. Can water hammer damage a valve?

Yes. Severe or repeated hydraulic transients can damage valve seats, discs, hinges, springs, actuators, and body components. They can also damage nearby flanges, gaskets, pipe supports, and piping.

 

7. How do I calculate water hammer pressure?

A first-pass estimate can use the Joukowsky equation:

ΔP = ρaΔV

For complex or critical systems, transient simulation is recommended because actual pressure peaks depend on the complete piping system and operating sequence.

 

8. Should I replace the valve if I have water hammer?

Not always.

First identify what is causing the transient. The correct solution may be a different check valve, slower actuator operation, improved pump control, or additional surge protection.

 

Send Inquiry